top of page

Weingarten Rights

  • Writer: Brikener Jean-Giles
    Brikener Jean-Giles
  • Jan 28, 2022
  • 5 min read

The Right to Request Representation During an Investigatory Interview

Section 7 of the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA) protects employees’ right to “self-organization, to form, join, or assist labor organizations, to bargain collectively through representatives of their own choosing, and to engage in other concerted activities for the purpose of collective bargaining or other mutual aid and protection”


he Right to Request Representation During an Investigatory Interview

Section 7 of the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA) protects employees’ right to “self-organization, to form, join, or assist labor organizations, to bargain collectively through representatives of their own choosing, and to engage in other concerted activities for the purpose of collective bargaining or other mutual aid and protection”


Among the rights protected by Section 7 is the right of union-represented employees, upon request, to have their representative present during an interview that the employee reasonably believes could lead to discipline. This right was first articulated by the Supreme Court in the case, NLRB v. J. Weingarten, Inc. In that case, the Court found that Section 7 of the NLRA protects employees who refuse to submit to certain interviews without a requested representative present.


An employee’s requested representative, which may be a union steward, business agent or officer, or fellow employee, is often referred to as a “Weingarten representative.” Weingarten representatives are entitled to provide advice and active assistance to employees during investigatory interviews. Employees’ right to request their representatives are frequently referred to as “Weingarten rights.”


Employers violate the NLRA if they proceed with an investigatory interview while refusing an employee’s request or retaliate against them for making the request. Depending on the circumstances of each case, the Board may order that the employer cease and desist, post a remedial notice, require the employer to repeat the interview with a union member present, or rescind and remedy discipline resulting from a Weingarten violation.




When do employees have a right to request a union representative?

An employee’s right to request a representative arises during an investigatory interview. A useful comparison is an individual’s Miranda right to an attorney when questioned by law enforcement. However, unlike the right to counsel in a Miranda setting, employers are not required to inform union members of their rights under Weingarten.


Any meeting may be an “investigatory interview” provided that the following occurs:

  • A manager, representative of management, or supervisor is seeking to question an employee.

  • The questioning is part of an investigation into the employee’s performance or work conduct. During an investigatory interview, a representative of management may require an employee to defend, explain, or admit misconduct or work performance issues that may form the basis for discipline or discharge.

  • The employee reasonably believes that the investigation may result in discharge, discipline, demotion, or other adverse consequence to their job status or working conditions.

  • The employee requests a union representative. Employers are not required to advise employees of their right to representation and third parties (including union representatives) may not make the request on behalf of the employee.


When making a request for a representative, the Board does not require that the employee specify that they need a “Weingarten” representative. Once an employee requests their representative, they are not required to repeat that request.


At times, it is not clear whether a meeting is investigatory or could lead to discipline. In those cases, the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) looks to the conduct of the meeting and the surrounding circumstances to determine if there was an investigatory purpose. The Board will consider such factors as the identity/status of the participants, the parties’ collective-bargaining agreement and disciplinary practices, whether there was a confrontational tone to the meeting, any notices or warnings issued prior to the meeting, or whether employees had been disciplined for similar misconduct.




What types of meetings are not covered by the Weingarten rule?

If the above conditions are met, any meeting between an employer and employee could trigger an employee’s Weingarten rights. However, not every meeting or employer questioning satisfies those conditions. For example, employers need not grant an employee’s request for a representative in the following situations:

  • Instructional meetings where an employee receives training or correction on work techniques. Meetings of this nature generally do not lead to discipline.

  • Meetings in which an employer informs an employee (or employees) of personnel policies. Often these meetings do not require questioning of employees and do not lead to discipline.

  • Meetings in which the employee is informed in advance that no discipline or adverse employment action will result from the interview.

  • Meetings about disciplinary decisions that have already been made. If an employer has made a final decision on a disciplinary action, a meeting with an employee to inform them of that decision is not considered investigatory. In the same vein, if an employee initiates a meeting to discuss a disciplinary action that they have experienced, that meeting is not investigatory in nature because any discipline that the employee has experienced has already occurred.

  • Meetings in which an employee is questioned as part of an investigation of another employee’s conduct or performance. For example, an employee who witnesses another employee’s misconduct is not entitled to Weingarten representation if they are questioned about what they observed.

Even in the above examples, however, the nature of a meeting may change as it progresses. If an employee reasonably believes that a meeting that commenced for some other purpose has become an investigatory interview, the Board will look to the above factors to determine if an employee’s request for a representative should have been honored.




Who may serve as an employee Weingarten representative?

An employee may choose their own representative, who may be a representative of the union or a fellow employee. Employers are required to honor that request, so long as that choice does not unduly interfere with the employer’s ability to conduct its investigation. Employees may not request a non-employee representative unless that individual is an officer or business agent of the employee’s union. For example, an employee may not request a private attorney or a family member as their Weingarten representative if that individual has no affiliation with the employee’s union.


How should an employer respond to an employee’s request for representation?

When an employee requests a representative during an investigatory interview, an employer may lawfully take one of three courses of action:

  1. The employer may grant the employee’s request and delay the interview until a representative is available.

  2. The employer may deny the request and immediately end the interview, or

  3. The employer may allow the employee to choose whether to proceed with the meeting without a representative or to end the interview.

If the employer denies the request and continues to ask questions, this could constitute an unfair labor practice. Also, it is an unfair labor practice for an employer to discipline an employee for refusing to answer questions without their union representative present.


What may a union representative do during an employee interview?

  • Union representatives serve as advisors and witnesses during employee interviews. Employers are required to inform union representatives as to the subject matter of the interview and allow time for that representative to meet with the employee prior to questioning.

  • During the interview, a union representative may ask the employer to clarify questions, give the employee advice on how to answer questions (within limits), and provide additional information to the employer after the questioning. A union representative may also object to questions if they are badgering, intimidating, or offensive.

What are the limitations on union representation during an employee interview?

  • When representing an employee during an investigatory interview, a union representative must remain civil and may not interfere with an employer’s legitimate efforts to conduct an investigation. An employer may lawfully remove a union representative from a meeting if they engage in disruptive or hostile behavior.

  • A union representative may not tell an employee what to say and may not advise employees to give false answers.

Comments


What does a Security Guard do?

Security Guards are typically employed by private individuals or businesses to protect people, property and assets. Their regular duties can vary from position to position depending on the needs of their employer, but they’re often required to physically monitor or patrol an area and ensure the safety of the people within the home or business. Some Security Guards work as part of a team, while others work independently. Security Guards can be freelancers, internal employees or contractors from a security company.

 

Security Guard Job Description: Top Duties and Qualifications

A Security Guard, or Security Officer, is responsible for protecting a person, organization or asset in the case of an incident. Their duties include monitoring a specific area, evicting trespassers and writing reports detailing any occurrences during their shift.

Security Guard duties and responsibilities

The overall duty of a Security Guard is to protect a company’s property, employees and visitors. Here are some of their typical daily responsibilities that you can include in a job description:

  • Patrolling and monitoring activities on the company’s premises regularly to discourage criminals and ensure the environment is safe and secure

  • Evicting trespassers and violators and detaining perpetrators while following legal protocols before relevant authorities arrive to take over

  • Controlling the entrance and departure of employees, visitors and vehicles according to protocols

  • Monitoring surveillance cameras to watch out for any disruptions or unlawful activities

  • Providing detailed reports on daily activities and any incidents that may have occurred to management

  • Testing security systems and, if needed, operating X-ray machines and metal detectors

  • Using provided communication devices such as two-way radios in a clear and concise manner

  • Performing CPR or first aid when needed

Security Guard salary expectations

A Security Guard makes an average of $12.92 per hour. This pay rate may vary depending on factors such as experience, education, certifications and additional skills. Unionized Security Guards make anywhere from $17.00 on a low end to over $30.00 an hour plus benefits based on the job type and location. For example the United Federation LEOS-PBA Paragon Security officers under our Paragon Protective Service Officers National Union, working at the federal buildings in New York City make $30.50 an hour plus they receive full benefits.

United Federation LEOS-PBA Law Enforcement Officers Security & Police Benevolent Association LEOS-PBA

Looking to Join or Form a Security Guard Union 
in your State or work location?

If so, Complete the Form Below Today!

Security Guard skills and qualifications

In order to ensure the safety of a company and its assets, a Security Guard should have the following skills and qualifications:

  • Excellent knowledge of security protocols

  • Ability to operate security systems and emergency equipment

  • Exceptional interpersonal skills

  • Advanced verbal and written communication skills

  • Ability to work alone or as part of a team

  • Ability to solve problems as they arise

  • Attention to detail

  • Ability to react appropriately in stressful situations

Security Guard education and training requirements

Unlike many other professional roles, the right candidate for a Security Guard position doesn’t need to have a degree. Most employers will consider applicants with a high school diploma or GED certificate. Companies typically give priority to candidates with a certification, a Security Guard license or security training. Candidates should also be trained in first aid and self-defense. For higher-level roles, employers may look for candidates with a four-year degree in criminal justice or a related field.

Security Guard experience requirements

Candidates applying for a Security Guard role should have at least a year of work experience. Employers may prefer applicants who have worked in the police force or the army or those who have previous experience as a Security Guard, Security Officer or another similar role. Candidates should also have demonstrable experience working with security systems, be proficient in Microsoft Office and know how to write reports.

CONTACT THE

UNITED FEDERATION

LEOS-PBA - DC

 

Address

1717 Pennsylvania Ave NW, 10th Floor

Washington, D.C. 20006

Phone
Office / Fax: (202) 595-3510
Organizing: (800) 516-0094

 

UFSPSO: (914) 941-4103

Fax: (914) 941-44722

NUSPO: (202) 499-3956

Fax: (202) 499-3956

NUNSO: (815) 900-9944

Fax: (815) 900-9944

PSONU: (877) - 60-PSONU

FAX:  (877) -607-7668

FPSOA: (202)-595-3510

Fax: (202) 595-3510

UFK9H  (800) 516-0094

Email

organizing@leospba.org

CONTACT EAST COAST

Address

New York City Office

17 State Street, 40th Floor

New York, NY 10004

Long Island Office

220 Old Country Road #2

Mineola, NY 11501

 

Phone
Office / Fax: (212) 457-1010
Organizing: (800) 516-0094

Email
organizing@leospba.org

CONTACT WEST COAST

Address

Los Angeles Office

ARCO Tower 1055 West 7th Street, 33rd Floor (Penthouse) Los Angeles, CA 90017

Phone
Office / Fax: (213) 205-1855
Organizing: (800) 516-0094

Hawaii Guam Saipan 808-212-9831

Email

organizing @leospba.org

Site Map

Lally & Misir LLP

Address

The Nassau Building

220 Old Country Road #2

Mineola, NY 11501

Phone: (516) 741-2666

Fax: (516) 742-8533

Website: https://www.lallymisir.co

BEINS AXELROD

Address

1717 K Street N.W.  Suite 1120 

Washington DC 20006 

Phone: (202) 328-7222

Fax: (202) 328-7030 

Website: http://www.beinsaxelrod.com

© 2022 by Security Guard Union | United Federation LEOS-PBA  all rights reserved

bottom of page